Consumer Protection Law

by Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC

  • About Us
  • Blogger Profiles
    • Joseph Alan Venti
    • Mark R. Cuker, Co-Founder and Partner
    • Michael Quirk
  • Conditions of Use/Disclaimers

CFPB Expansion of Protections from Foreclosure and Mortgage-Servicing Abuses: Current Rules and New Proposals

Posted by Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC on December 1, 2014
Posted in: Uncategorized. Leave a comment

We are closing in on one year since the January 10, 2014 effective date of a set of new rules intended to protect homeowners struggling with their monthly mortgage payments.  The rules—enacted by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (“the CFPB”) under the Dodd-Frank amendments to the federal Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (“RESPA”)—force banks and other mortgage-loan servicers to engage homeowners in a process designed to lead out of default, instead of into foreclosure.

Among those rules are requirements that servicers:  (1) establish live contact within 36 days of payment delinquency (12 C.F.R. § 1024.39(a)); (2) provide a notice outlining loss mitigation options, within 45 days of payment delinquency (12 C.F.R. § 1024.39(b)); and (3) in most cases withhold from filing a foreclosure complaint until at least 120 days after payment delinquency (12 C.F.R. § 1024.41(f)(1)).  In addition, servicers generally cannot request a foreclosure judgment or conduct a sale of the home if a completed application for loss mitigation (e.g. loan modifications, forbearance agreements) is submitted more than 37 days in advance of any sale of the home (12 C.F.R. § 1024.41(g)).  If the servicer receives a loss mitigation application within 90 days of any sale, a number of protections kick in:  (1) the servicer has 5 business days to acknowledge receipt of a completed application; (2) if the application is deemed incomplete, the servicer must identify what is missing; (3) within 30 days of receipt of a completed application, the servicer must make a decision on loss mitigation; (4) if loss mitigation is denied, the servicer has to identify the specific reasons for denial, and the borrower has 14 days to appeal; and (5) if loss mitigation is offered, the homeowner has 14 days to accept or reject the offer. (see 12 C.F.R. §§ 1024.41(b)(2), (c), (d), (e)(1), and (h)).  A homeowner may sue a servicer for damages and attorney’s fees for violating any of the rules mentioned in this paragraph (see 12 U.S.C. §§ 2605(f) and 2605(k)(1)(E)).

These rules have helped homeowners transition from delinquency to affordable monthly payments.  HOPE NOW, an alliance of banks, industry-minded nonprofits and other organizations, has released data from the third quarter of 2014 showing that almost half a million homeowners received “non-foreclosure solutions from mortgage servicers in July, August and September.”  Increased loss mitigation may also be a factor in the substantial reduction of delinquencies nationwide.  As one writer at MarketWatch.com recently reported, data from Black Knight Financial Services shows that “about 3.8 million loans in the U.S. were delinquent as of September 2014, down from a high of 7.7 million in January 2010.”

Nevertheless, abuses continue.  We have observed that abuses occur more frequently where the servicer is of medium size (measured by volume of loans serviced):  too big to claim small-servicer exemption f, but perhaps believing itself to be too small to dedicate sufficient resources to ensure regulatory compliance.

The CFPB has been closely watching the impact of the rules rolled out earlier this year, reaching out to both consumer advocacy groups and mortgage industry representatives.  And, on November 20, 2014, the CFPB announced proposed rule amendments that would further strengthen protections against servicing abuses.  The amendments would “require servicers to provide certain borrowers with foreclosure protections more than once over the life of the loan, to put in place additional servicing transfer protections, and to take steps to protect borrowers from a wrongful foreclosure sale.”  The amendments would also clearly define what it means to be “delinquent” on a mortgage loan, clarify servicers’ responsibilities to make “live contact” with struggling homeowners, and make sure that successors in interest—people who inherit or receive property when there is still an outstanding mortgage loan on the property—have full rights under the CFPB’s servicing rules.  Another greatly needed amendment “would permit servicers to offer, based on an evaluation of an incomplete application, a short-term repayment plan that allows the borrower to repay past due payments over a specified period of time until the mortgage loan account is current.”

For information on how to submit comments on the CFPB’s proposed amendments or to report misconduct by your mortgage-loan servicer, visit http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201411_cfpb_proposed-rule_mortgage-servicing.pdf and http://www.consumerfinance.gov/, respectively.

How Loan Mods could have saved the economy Part II.

Posted by Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC on August 19, 2014
Posted in: Uncategorized. Leave a comment

“Safety and Soundness [of the banks] was their priority.  They did not put their heart and soul into helping homeowners”.  Former Senator Ted Kaufman Delaware quoted in Other Peoples Houses by Jennifer Taub.

In a prior blog post https://consumerprotectionlawblog.wordpress.com/2014/07/09/how-loan-modifications-could-have-saved-the-economy/ we noted how two noted economists found that the massive loss of equity by less affluent homeowners in the real estate crash of 2007-2009 dealt a devastating blow to the economy and how a vigorous loan modification programsproviding for principal reductions would have gotten homes above water, restored a sense of dignity and self-worth to their owners and stimulated the economy out of its doldrums.  That did not happen.

In Other Peoples Houses, Jennifer Taub takes the analysis one step further, giving us an eye-popping history of how  the downward spiral in financial deregulation  culminated in the Crash of 2008.  Peering back in time to the savings and loan debacle of the 1980s, she tells how banks used their special interest power, political connections and lobbying clout to get push through one new law after another– each piece of legislation carefully tailored to allow banks to take on more risk while taking away rights of consumers to sue them for unfair practices.

The centerpiece of Professor Taub’s story is the case of Nobelman v. American Savings Bank, in which the U.S. Supreme Court precluded bankruptcy courts from reducing mortgage principal, even when the homes were far under water—the only type of loan which bankruptcy courts are not allowed to modify.   Even in October, 2008, when the banks were reeling and in desperately need of  a federal bailout, Congress (with the connivance of both presidential candidates) failed to change this law lift the burden on homeowners overwhelmed with toxic debt.  Professor Taub labels this “the great betrayal”.

Professor Taub concludes “it was okay to short someone’s house through credit derivatives, commit trillions of dollars to rescue the banking system, and fail to prosecute the top bankers who facilitated the fraud, but not to help save other people’s houses.  Yet, if foreclosures were stemmed, the value of our homes would be protected, our neighborhoods made safer, and public services and private sector jobs maintained.”  Other People’s Houses, p. 265.

No one has ever said it better.

How Loan Modifications Could Have Saved the Economy

Posted by Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC on July 9, 2014
Posted in: Uncategorized. Leave a comment

“The overwhelming bias of economists and policy makers during the heart of the Great Recession was towards saving banks at all costs.”  Atif Mian and Amir Sufi House of Debt, p.142.

In 2008, Jon Stewart reacted to the proposed bank bailout by asking a question on the mind of many others:  “Why not take the $700 Billion and give it directly to people – why are we giving it to the banks that created this issue?”  That question has been asked, with much more force, in a fascinating new book called House of Debt.  The book examines how the mortgage crisis which precipitated the economic crash of 2008 disproportionately hurt less affluent families whose homes were heavily mortgaged.  The crash of property values at the end of the real estate bubble wiped out the equity of millions of low income home owners, taking away virtually all of their assets.  This caused them to cut back their spending to a far greater extent than high income people who lost a much lower percentage of equity in their homes.

As a result, the housing crash hurt the economy far greater than the dot com crash of 2000-2002, even though the same amount of “wealth” — $5 Trillion — was lost in both debacles.  As the authors sum it up “the financial system’s reliance on debt means that those with most wealth were protected when house prices fell, while those with the least were hammered.”  The collapse in house prices caused a massive collapse of net worth of highly indebted home owners.  When they radically cut back their spending as a result, the economy plunged into deep recession with huge loss of jobs across the country.

It didn’t have to happen.  There was and still is an obvious solution.  An aggressive loan modification  program which would eliminate negative equity and give people an incentive to stay in their homes and make their mortgages affordable was required.  (https://consumerprotectionlawblog.wordpress.com/2014/06/01/12-things-you-should-know-about-loan-modifications/)  It did not happen.  As late as 2011, eleven million properties, 23% of all properties with a mortgage, were under water, i.e. had negative equity.  Indeed, as recently as the first quarter of 2014 nearly 6.3 million homes, or 12.7% of all residential properties with a mortgage, still had negative equity.  The government’s main mortgage modification program, HAMP, failed miserably.  Although HAMP had a goal of modifying 5 million mortgages, only about 865,000 actually achieved a final HAMP modification.  Thus more than five years after the crash of 2008, the housing market remains depressed in many parts of the country and homeowners are being dragged down by unsustainable levels of debt.

It is not too late to turn this around.  The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has issued regulations effective in January 2014 making foreclosures more difficult and encouraging more aggressive loss mitigation and loan modification procedures. http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201312_cfpb_foreclosure-avoidance-procedures.pdf.  Courts have been increasingly inclined to recognize the rights of homeowners who have been denied the benefit of loan modification agreements they have entered into.  http://www.wcblegal.com/in-the-news/wcb-sues-bank-america-breaching-loan-modification-agreement-2.

Homeowners should receive the same treatment as banks.  Saving banks without saving homeowners leaves the economy an empty shell.

Federal Court Finds Pressler and Pressler’s Four-Second Debt-Collection Complaint Review to Violate FDCPA

Posted by Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC on July 7, 2014
Posted in: Uncategorized. Leave a comment

            A New Jersey consumer has obtained a federal court judgment against debt-collection law firm Pressler and Pressler, LLP, finding that its minimal attorney-review process before it filed a collection complaint against the consumer violated the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (“FDCPA”).

             In Bock v. Pressler and Pressler, LLP, a New Jersey consumer, Daniel Bock, Jr., claimed that Pressler made a false or misleading representation under the FDCPA by filing a debt-collection complaint against him without having an attorney perform any meaningful prior review.  In fact, virtually all of Pressler’s pre-filing work on the collection claim it filed against Mr. Bock was done by non-lawyers.

             More importantly, Pressler’s computer records show that the attorney who signed the collection complaint against Mr. Bock spent a total of only four seconds reviewing the electronic case file before approving the complaint.  Moreover, no one at Pressler ever reviewed Mr. Bock’s credit card account (on which the collection claim was based) or the assignment of this alleged debt to Midland Funding LLC, the debt-buyer that Pressler represented.

             Based on this undisputed evidence, United States District Court for the District of New Jersey Judge Kevin McNulty held that Pressler violated the FDCPA by filing the collection complaint against Mr. Bock in court and thereby impliedly representing that an attorney had meaningfully reviewed the claims, when this was false.  As the court explained:

The claimed misrepresentation here does not relate to the ultimate veracity of the numbered factual allegations of the complaint; it concerns the veracity of the implied representation that an attorney was meaningfully involved in the preparation of the complaint.  If, in fact, an attorney who signed the complaint is not involved and familiar with the case against the debtor, then the debtor has been unfairly misled and deceived within the meaning of the FDCPA.

             Turning to the facts of the case, the court held that the Pressler attorney’s “rapid look-over of the complaint against Bock, one of 673 complaints he reviewed that day, cannot really be considered a careful review of the complaint, let alone an exercise of the professional skills of a lawyer.”  The court thus held that Pressler’s implied representation that an attorney had reviewed the collection complaint before it was filed in court was false and misleading, and therefore violated the FDCPA.

             The federal court’s ruling against Pressler may be significant for many New Jersey consumers.  As the case facts show, Pressler files hundreds of debt-collection actions every day using the same assembly-line review process that the court found to violate the FDCPA.  The thousands of New Jersey consumers who have been sued in these collection actions by Pressler and Pressler may therefore have viable FDCPA claims for money damages against the firm.

 

By Michael J. Quirk, Esq.

U.S. Court of Appeals Allows Unfair Debt Collection Claim

Posted by Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC on June 30, 2014
Posted in: Uncategorized. Leave a comment

A Pennsylvania consumer may sue a debt collector under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) for misrepresenting amounts the consumer owes in a collection letter, the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit recently held in McLaughlin v. Phelan Hallinan & Schmieg, LLP.

The McLaughlin case was brought by a consumer who fell behind on his mortgage payments due to an error by his lender. When Phelan Hallinan & Schmieg, LLP attempted to collect the alleged debt, its collection letter listed charges of $650 for attorney’s fees and $550 for costs of suit. In fact, the actual fees and costs Phelan incurred were $625 and $440 respectively. The consumer filed suit against Phelan, claiming that it violated the FDCPA by misrepresenting and attempting to collect these charges.

The Third Circuit held in its June 26, 2014 opinion that the consumer stated well-founded FDCPA claims. First, the court rejected Phelan’s argument that it was not engaged in “debt collection activity” because its letter did not demand payment. Since the letter stated that Phelan is a “debt collector attempting to collect a debt, the court held this was clearly collection activity.

Second, the court rejected Phelan’s argument that the amounts stated were allowable “estimates” of amounts owed because Phelan’s letter nowhere said these were estimates. Instead, the collection letter stated that these amounts were for work performed as of a particular date, and were part of the total amount the consumer owed.

Finally, the court rejected Phelan’s argument that the consumer could not bring suit without first contesting these charges directly to Phelan. The court recognized that the FDCPA allows a consumer to directly contest the validity of a debt, but held that this does not mean that the consumer must do so before bringing suit. The court explained that “imposing a requirement that the debtor challenge the validity of the debt described in a communication before filing suit would have the effect of immunizing false statements that a consumer failed to promptly dispute.” This, the court continued, “would be inconsistent with the FDCPA’s goal of ensuring debt collectors act responsibly.”

We have seen evidence that the practice alleged here of marking up the actual charges incurred is common in foreclosure actions. If you suspect this has happened to you or if you have received misleading or harassing debt-collection letters or calls and believe your rights were violated, WCB’s consumer attorneys Michael Quirk (mquirk@wcblegal.com) or Joseph Venti (joeventi@wcblegal.com) may be able to assist you.

By Michael Quirk

NACA Issues Third Edition of Consumer Class Action Guidelines

Posted by Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC on June 6, 2014
Posted in: Uncategorized. Leave a comment

The National Association of Consumer Advocates (“NACA”) has issued the third edition of its Standards and Guidelines for Litigating and Settling Consumer Class Actions, available at http://tinyurl.com/p52jn6z.  NACA is a non-profit association of private, public sector, and legal services lawyers, law professors, and law students whose mission is to promote justice for all consumers by maintaining a forum for information-sharing among advocates, fighting unfair and abusive business practices, and promoting ethical and effective representation of consumers.

The NACA Class Action Guidelines are an attempt to establish a consensus of ethical and effective practices for representing consumers in class action litigation.  The Guidelines address a wide range of issues arising in consumer class actions, including the propriety of class actions when individual recoveries are small, when if ever class action settlements providing certificate, or “coupon” relief may be appropriate, and the proper uses of “cy pres” awards in class action settlements.  The Guidelines also address the special considerations that arise in consumer class actions involving home-ownership, such as cases challenging predatory mortgage lending or abusive loan servicing practices.

The first two editions of the NACA Class Action Guidelines were adopted in 1997 and 2006 respectively.  The third edition, adopted in May 2014, was drafted by a committee of class action lawyers and consumer advocates comprised of:

  • Michael Quirk, Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC;
  • Steve Gardner, Center for Science in the Public Interest (Committee Chair);
  • Rob Bramson, Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhauser, LLP;
  • Seth Lesser, Klafter Olsen & Lesser, LLP;
  • Stuart Rossman, National Consumer Law Center; and
  • Brian Wolfman, Georgetown University Law Center’s Institute for Public Representation.

By Michael J. Quirk, Esquire

CFPB Orders Bank of America to Pay $727 Million for Illegal Credit Card Charges

Posted by Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC on June 6, 2014
Posted in: Uncategorized. Leave a comment

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has ordered Bank of America, N.A. and FIA Card Services, N.A. to refund consumers an estimated $727 million for improper charges the bank collected for certain payment protection and credit security services (http://www.consumerfinance.gov/newsroom/cfpb-orders-bank-of-america-to-pay-727-million-in-consumer-relief-for-illegal-credit-card-practices/).  The CFPB’s orders require Bank of America and FIA to pay almost three million of their credit card customers back for these services that the bank deceptively sold and unfairly billed for without providing the promised services.

The payment protection services were called “Credit Protection Plus” and “Credit Protection Deluxe.”  These were supposed to be optional services for an added charge that would allow customers to cancel part of a credit card debt in the event of a hardship.  The CFPB found that Bank of America and FIA deceptively marketed these services by misrepresenting that they were free for 30 days, enrolling customers who had only requested information about the services, and misrepresenting the available benefits (such as a $25,000 death benefit that was not actually available).  The CFPB found that over 1.4 million Bank of America and FIA credit card customers lost money through these deceptive marketing practices.

The credit security services were called “Privacy Guard,” “Privacy Source,” and “Privacy Assist.”  These were supposed to monitor customer accounts and provide alerts about potentially fraudulent activity.  For Bank of America and FIA to perform these services, they had to obtain authorization of access to credit information from the customer.  The CFPB found, however, that Bank of America and FIA were unfairly billing customers for these services without ever obtaining the authorizations that were necessary to perform these services.  The CFPB found that approximately 1.9 million Bank of America and FIA credit card customers were unfairly billed for these services that were not and could not be fully performed.

The CFPB’s enforcement order requires Bank of America and FIA to refund approximately $727 million to their credit card customers for these deceptive marketing and unfair billing practices, to stop billing customers for any of these services that are not provided, and to stop marketing these services until they submit a compliance plan to the CFPB.

By Michael J. Quirk, Esquire

Predatory Lending – How Mandatory Arbitration Helps Payday Lenders Fleece Consumers

Posted by Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC on June 6, 2014
Posted in: Uncategorized. Leave a comment

The New York Times has a terrific piece (http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/magazine/how-payday-lenders-prey-upon-the-poor-and-the-courts-dont-help.html?_r=0) this weekend by Emily Bazelon on how payday lenders get away with charging 300 to 500% interest on short-term loans that push many consumers into bottomless debt cycles.  Many states prohibit loans with interest rates over 10, 20, or 30%.  Yet today, very few borrowers can enforce these laws against payday lenders.  How did these purveyors of high cost consumer debt immunize themselves from state usury laws?  The answer, according to Bazelon, is mandatory arbitration.

Hidden in the fine print of virtually every payday loan agreement is a clause that prohibits borrowers from bringing a lawsuit in court, requires them instead to go to a private and secret arbitration, and bars them from being part of a class action.  As a result, consumers cannot bring their claims together to obtain systemic relief against payday lenders.  How well do these mandatory arbitration clauses protect payday lenders?

All too well, as Bazelon explains.  In the state of North Carolina, the arbitration clause provisions banning class actions used to be unenforceable.  At that time, three consumer class action cases against different payday lenders resulted in settlements requiring the lenders to pay over $37 million to borrowers for the excessive interest charges.  In 2011, however, the United States Supreme Court decided a case called AT&T Mobility, LLC v. Concepcion, and held that a federal statute, the Federal Arbitration Act, requires states to enforce arbitration clause provisions banning class actions.  Since the Supreme Court’s Concepcion decision, Bazelon reports that courts have thrown out over 130 class action cases, including an identical one in North Carolina against another payday lender, which got away scot-free with charging the same excessive interest rates.

We have seen the exact same thing here.  In 2007, Williams Cuker Berezofsky settled a class action challenging high-interest rent-to-own sales by Rent-A-Center in New Jersey, and recovered $109 million(http://www.wcblegal.com/success/perez-v-rent-center) for consumers.  Four years later, a case we filed against a high-interest payday lender in Pennsylvania could not be brought as a class action after Concepcion was decided, and so borrowers could not hold the lender to account.

Fortunately, this story is not over yet.  The federal consumer protection regulator, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, has authority to issue regulations banning or restricting mandatory arbitration clauses and is in the middle of studying (http://www.consumerfinance.gov/newsroom/the-cfpb-finds-few-consumers-file-arbitration-cases/) how these clauses affect consumer rights and the public interest.  The answer should be obvious.

By Michael J. Quirk, Esquire

CFPB Asks For Increased Credit-Score Disclosure

Posted by Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC on June 6, 2014
Posted in: Uncategorized. Leave a comment

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau continues to be a beacon of positive change for the American consumer.  In February of this year, CFPB Director Richard Cordray wrote to top credit-card companies, strongly encouraging them “to make the credit scores on which you rely available to your customers regularly and freely, along with educational content to help them make use of this information.”  If adopted, the change would benefit most consumers; citing information from one of the three major credit reporting agencies, Fred O. Williams writes that “About 157 million Americans have one or more credit cards . . . meaning free credit scores would be widely available if card issuers adopt the policy widely.” (note:  that figure appears to have stayed constant for almost fifteen years).

Director Cordray is calling for change because those three digits that make up your credit score are incredibly important.  The score is widely used by creditors in deciding whether to extend credit and, if extended, the terms of that credit.  In fact, sometimes the score is the only criterion used for the credit-extension decision.

Unfortunately, your credit score is currently not included in the free report you obtain through annualcreditreport.com.  Instead, only for a fee will each of the three major credit reporting agencies (Equifax, Experian, TransUnion) include your credit score with the report.  Also, while some companies may offer a “free” credit score, beware the catch:  to receive the score you will likely have to sign up and pay for an ancillary service like credit monitoring.  Remember the old adage, ‘there ain’t no such thing as a free lunch’.

True, your credit score may be disclosed to you, without a request, in a variety of contexts.  But those are generally situations in which you are getting bad news about your creditworthiness.  According to the CFPB’s website:

Creditors (including card issuers) generally have to disclose your credit score (and related information) if they use the score and:

  • deny your application,
  • increase the cost of your credit, or
  • offer you a higher rate than other consumers get from that creditor.

Mortgage lenders also have to disclose your score when they check your score to approve a mortgage loan.

By then, as Director Cordray observes in his February 2014 letter, the consumer has learned of his or her credit standing “when it is too late.”

There may be a legislative fix on the horizon, as United States Senators Sherrod Brown (D-OH) and Brian Schatz (D-HI) are pushing forward a bill that would, among other things, provide consumers with the ability to request their credit scores at no charge once annually.  The Senators’ press release for the new legislation—called the Stop Errors in Credit Use and Reporting Act (SECURE)— quotes a senior policy counsel from Consumers Union as saying that “Free access to credit scores will help consumers know where they stand with lenders and others when it comes to their credit record.”

Even if there were a dramatic increase in the availability of credit scores, though, the consumer must still be vigilant in checking his or her credit report, from which the credit score is derived (the exact methods of calculation by the credit bureaus are, however, closely guarded secrets).  This is especially true because, as Kaitlyn Wells has noted on MarketWatch, “with 36 billion pieces of credit reporting data flying throughout the ether, any given score can change rapidly. There’s an average of 15 changes to a credit file each month for every consumer.”

* * *

One rotten ingredient can lead to a rotten stew even if all the other ingredients are fresh.  In that same way, even a single inaccuracy on your credit report (a wrongfully reported mortgage delinquency, for example) can ruin your credit score and lead to adverse credit decisions.  Make sure that rotten vegetable does not get used!  Go to http://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0155-free-credit-reports today to learn how to request your free credit report, and be sure to give it a thorough read.

By Joseph Alan Venti, Esq.

One FCRA Violation Leads To Another

Posted by Williams Cuker Berezofsky, LLC on June 6, 2014
Posted in: Uncategorized. Leave a comment

In May 2013, we sued Bank of America (BOA) and the three biggest credit reporting agencies (the CRAs), contending that our clients’ credit reports inaccurately said they were delinquent on their mortgage payments during a three-month loan modification trial period.  These clients had never, ever missed a mortgage payment, and had made each of their trial period payments exactly as prescribed by BOA.  We claimed that the failures of BOA and the CRAs to correct the inaccuracies on the credit reports violated the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA).  This case was previously discussed on our website.  The Amended Complaint we filed is viewable here.

Eight months into the litigation, the clients received their free credit reports (once every twelve months, the CRAs are obligated to provide you with a free report detailing the contents of your credit file, see 15 U.S.C. § 1681j).  To their surprise, the clients discovered that, starting in May 2013 (when suit was filed), BOA had stopped reporting their mortgage payments to the CRAs.  The reports thus inaccurately displayed the clients’ mortgage payment history, and also inaccurately reflected the total balance due on the mortgage.  In other words, despite timely, full payments of principal and interest on their mortgage account, from May 2013 onward, any potential credit-grantor would be deceived into thinking that principal on the loan had not been reduced by one penny during that time!

We have learned that it is BOA policy to stop reporting to the CRAs about accounts that are disputed in litigation.  As demonstrated in our clients’ case, during the pendency of the lawsuit BOA will continue to report the disputed information but nevertheless block out accurate account information that postdates the filing of suit.  In this case it was a mortgage account at issue, but in others it could just as easily be a credit card or a checking account in dispute.

We believe that BOA’s post-suit reporting practice can make a litigant’s credit report highly misleading if not patently inaccurate, and can thus serve as the basis for claims under the FCRA.  If you are currently in suit with BOA, consider talking to your lawyer about this issue.  If you are unrepresented and live in Pennsylvania, New Jersey or Delaware(1), we encourage you to contact Williams Cuker Bereozfsky attorney Joseph Venti at 215-557-0099 for more information on how to protect your rights.

By Joseph Alan Venti, Esq.

(1) We regularly associate with Delaware counsel to litigate on behalf of residents in that State. However, our firm does not maintain an office in Delaware, nor are any of the firm’s attorneys licensed to practice in Delaware.

 

Posts navigation

← Older Entries
  • Recent Posts

    • CFPB Expansion of Protections from Foreclosure and Mortgage-Servicing Abuses: Current Rules and New Proposals
    • How Loan Mods could have saved the economy Part II.
    • How Loan Modifications Could Have Saved the Economy
    • Federal Court Finds Pressler and Pressler’s Four-Second Debt-Collection Complaint Review to Violate FDCPA
    • U.S. Court of Appeals Allows Unfair Debt Collection Claim
  • Recent Comments

    How Loan Modificatio… on 12 Things You Should Know Abou…
  • Archives

    • December 2014
    • August 2014
    • July 2014
    • June 2014
  • Categories

    • Uncategorized
  • Meta

    • Create account
    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.com
Blog at WordPress.com.
Consumer Protection Law
Blog at WordPress.com.
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Subscribe Subscribed
    Consumer Protection Law

    Have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.

  • Consumer Protection Law
    View site in Reader
    Manage subscriptionsSign upLog in
    Report this content
    Collapse this bar
Loading Comments...